Skip to content

US judge acquits brothers who took $25 million from Ethereum bots

Category
News
Published
Reading time
2 min

In a 12-second operation in April 2023, two former MIT students took $25 million from automated Ethereum bots using eight fake bait trades. A Manhattan court ruled the deception evidence fell short of fraud.

US District Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on Nov. 16 of charges tied to a $25 million scheme against Ethereum trading bots, closing the first criminal prosecution in the United States over blockchain transaction-ordering manipulation.

According to the US Department of Justice, the brothers, who ran their own Ethereum validator, arranged the order of transactions in a block they produced in April 2023 and inserted eight bait trades. Automated trading bots run by other users then bought assets at inflated prices, and the brothers pocketed the difference in 12 seconds.

Clarke wrote that prosecutors failed to prove the brothers made any material misrepresentation that anyone relied on, a required element of wire fraud. She called Ethereum “a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use,” unlike regulated markets.

Conduct that is “improper, objectionable, or even despicable” is not enough to prove fraud, Clarke added. The ruling threw out the wire-fraud count along with the related conspiracy charges covering fraud and the laundering of proceeds. About $3 million of the proceeds remains frozen in one wallet.

Prosecutors indicted the brothers, both MIT graduates, in May 2024. A jury deadlocked in November 2025, leading to a mistrial before Clarke's acquittal closed the case.